(Yes, yes, I said the last one was final, but I’ve thought up two more to address things unanswered)
Usually, when a policy is reformed for the better, the reformers are lauded as heroes. But in the case of Jehovah’s Witnesses and the update on blood transfusion policies, this has not been enough to satisfy detractors. Those detractors want “accountability.”
Well, I suppose you could always blame the prior policy on someone now dead and be done with it. That’s what most everyone else does; why should only Witnesses be expected to do it differently? The old policy, favoring collective conscience rather than individual conscience with regard to “abstaining from blood” (Acts 15:29) has now been reversed to individual over collective. It dates from 1945. Surely, everyone involved in its formation is now dead. Most institutions routinely employ this strategy. Woes are always the fault of the previous administration, not the current one. Nor does everything change on Day 1. It invariably takes a long time to turn the ship around.
Nothing happens in a vacuum. World War II put blood transfusions on the front page. No longer was transfusion an occasional or experimental thing. It instantly became routine, a large-scale medical technique. Its new-found popularity quickly moved from the battlefield to that of civilians. It would have been enough to trigger anyone alert to the Acts 15 stricture. It would have been analogous to Thomas Bartholin (professor from the 1600s) sounding the alarm when experiments first began in transfusing blood from one being into another:
“Those who drag in the use of human blood for internal remedies of diseases appear to misuse it and to sin gravely,” he wrote. “Cannibals are condemned. Why do we not abhor those who stain their gullet with human blood? Similar is the receiving of alien blood from a cut vein, either through the mouth or by instruments of transfusion. The authors of this operation are held in terror by the divine law, by which the eating of blood is prohibited.”
So, in their own context of World War II, Jehovahs Witnesses began implementing the policy that has only now been changed. Might the old policy have triggered some deaths among members? If so, it was dwarfed by the price the greater world was fully prepared to pay with regard to World War—or at least it was prepared to draft its young men and make them pay it. Their deaths became societally acceptable—even laudable. It is in this context, not the one in which death of a young person is an unimaginable horror for which someone ought be held accountable, that Jehovah’s Witnesses determined blood transfusion violated the Bible prohibition on blood misuse.
Consideration of context opens one up to charges of “what aboutism.” That is, it opens one up to charges evading the question by shifting the focus to a greater example. I realize that the retort of “what aboutism” is considered an intellegent answer today, but, C’mon! When you ignore the iceberg to obsess over the ice cube, what does that say about you?
****** The bookstore
Leave a Reply